Inclusive classroom practice

“Staff members hold a lot of power within the classroom context, and are central to ensuring that the classroom environment and the educational experience are inclusive and representative of everyone,” says Busiswe Deyi, a lecturer in the Department of Jurisprudence at the University of Pretoria (UP) whose research and consultancy work focuses on gender equality. “This includes utilising practices and educational material that make students feel represented in the classroom.”

Before cultivating an inclusive environment for trans/gender non-conforming students (and colleagues), it is important that staff members cultivate self-awareness about their own assumptions around gender.

Pierre Brouard, Deputy Director of UP’s Centre for Sexualities, AIDS and Gender, suggests that lecturers and tutors reflect on your own gender and gender identity by asking themselves: how do I understand my own gender and how did I know which gender I was?

Also examine any general gender-related assumptions that you may have. The Centre for Research on Learning and Teaching at the University of Michigan suggests thinking about questions such as:

  • How often do I expect that a person’s appearance will reflect their gender identity, sexuality or pronoun use?
  • How often do I make a judgement about what a person “should” look like based on my ideas about gender?
  • How often do I presume that knowing a person’s gender identity gives me insight into their experiences, competencies and goals?

The next step is for staff to translate their re-examined outlook on gender into practically reorienting a faculty, department or unit towards more gender-inclusive practices. Brouard offers a few suggestions on where to begin:

  • Familiarise yourself with the contents and glossary of UP’s Trans Protocol
  • Have discussions in your teams/units/departments about gender-inclusive practices  and agree on basic principles and actions.
  • Support staff and students who are transitioning.
  • Actively do anti-stigma work such as running workshops, disseminating gender-inclusive guidelines and taking harmful incidents that trans and gender-diverse students report seriously.
  • Aim to allocate at least one gender-neutral bathroom in your department/unit.
  • Send out memos to staff and students that indicate that, in line with UP’s Anti-discrimination Policy and Trans Protocol, everyone – irrespective of whether they identify as transgender, cisgender or as gender diverse – is welcome to use gender titles, pronouns and the name of their choice in official communication, on online platforms and in meetings.
  • Explore the use of gendered language in official documents and forms: in some cases, the requirement for sex/gender is unnecessary, but where it is absolutely required, give people the opportunity to self-identify.
  • Hold meetings/discussions about gender diversity and how a particular space will welcome such diversity: where possible, people who are gender diverse should be invited to lead the conversation and not be spoken for.
  • Hold conversations about traditions, practices, habits and rituals – everything that contributes to what we might call (gendered) institutional culture.
Reorienting students

Students who do not identify as trans or gender non-conforming also need to be sensitised towards inclusive ideas related to gender to encourage awareness and more considered interaction with their trans peers. Brouard offers staff the following insights on how to bring students into the frame:

  • Think about the classroom context (online or in person) and what kind of culture around gender you wish to create. This could be around patriarchy, gender-based violence, respect for equality, as well as thinking beyond unhelpful binaries.
  • Hold discussions on gender and on the Trans Protocol with students, and hear out all views.
  • Some might position the Trans Protocol as a new orthodoxy, as a form of political correctness, as a denial of one’s views and freedom of speech. Hear people out, but note that there has always been an unquestioned “dominant” voice around gender; this is a privileged voice with power to define the terms and conditions of many spaces. Trans dignity is not a lot to ask for and trans voices have historically been side-lined or silenced.

As a lecturer or tutor, how can you cultivate gender-inclusive learning environments? These practical pointers will give you an idea of how to make trans and gender-questioning students feel at ease in class; employ gender-neutral language in class; and begin the process of including trans perspectives in curricular material.

  1. Invite students to share their preferred names and pronouns.

“I have a basic rule,” says University of Pretoria (UP) Law lecturer Busiswe Deyi, who identifies as non-binary. “I never assume a person’s pronouns. This allows me to interact with everyone by giving them space to self-define when interacting with me. I value people, spaces and conditions that allow me to identify the pronouns that feel safe for me at a particular time, which is why I try to open up a similar space for my students and colleagues.”

It is important to note that trans and gender non-conforming students should not be expected to make compulsory disclosures, as some may be experiencing gender-based marginalisation and/or violence. Rather, they should be given a choice as to whether to disclose information about themselves. 

Deyi and Pierre Brouard, Deputy Director of UP’s Centre for Sexualities, AIDS and Gender, provide a few guidelines on how to encourage inclusive communication in the classroom: 

  • When introducing yourself to students for the first time, include your pronouns.
  • Include your pronouns in your email signature and on the introductory page of the department’s Study Guide. Use the sample below to guide you:

  • Give students the opportunity to use “they/them/their” pronouns in papers to refer to a singular person, rather than less gender-inclusive options like “he or she”/“him or her”. Or for better clarity, indicate to them that they can repeat the noun: the complainant, the representative, the member, the person, etc.
  • Include a more detailed section on pronoun etiquette  in the faculty’s Study Guide and on clickUP, and briefly go through it with students throughout the first week/s of teaching until they gain familiarity with usage.
  • Signal to students that use of preferred pronouns is welcome. Perhaps this could be done at the beginning of the year and at the start of new course, new groups and new semesters.
  • Remind students that they can update their pronoun designations  and preferred names on the UP Portal.
  • Provide students with this sample email , which gives them a private channel through which to share how they would like to be addressed.
  • Indicate to students that if they do not feel comfortable correcting you in public, they can approach you during your consultation hours or via email.
  1. Use replacement language to avoid gender assumptions.

“Utilise gender-neutral language in your teaching, where this applies and makes sense,” Deyi says. “While pronouns are important, there will be moments where gender or gendering language is important to the topic, such as in explaining the history of marital power in South Africa in relation to gender and patriarchy.”

“Try to avoid binary language in communications,” Brouard adds. “When addressing others in public and on other platforms, terminology such as ‘ladies and gentlemen’ is unhelpful in recognising the multiplicity of gender identities.”

  • Instead of “ladies and gentlemen” or other language that assumes only two genders, you could use: friends; colleagues; esteemed guests; children/youngsters; or students.
  • Rather than calling upon a particular “man” or “woman” (who has not disclosed that identity), you could indicate:
    • The person in the red shirt.
    • The person with their hand raised.
    • The person who just spoke.
    • The person over here (gesturing).
  • Instead of “he or she” (when speaking of an unknown or universal person), use they; that person; the patron; or the guest.
  • Instead of “men and women”, you could say (meaning-dependent): everyone; all people; people of all genders; women, men and non-binary people.
  1. Consider adding a gender-inclusion statement to your syllabus. 

Adding such as statement demonstrates a commitment to fostering an inclusive classroom environment that welcomes students across the gender spectrum. The statement should provide students with a definition of gender inclusivity. Refer to the University’s Trans Protocol to guide your formulation.

  1. Give students clear guidelines on gender-inclusive participation.

Provide all students – no matter how they self-identify – with concrete examples of gender-inclusive ways to address one another and participate in discussions, including guidance on using pronouns and what do when mistakes are made .

  1. Rethink the curriculum.

In an effort to move away from material that reinforces gender hierarchies and exclusion, Deyi suggests being intentional about including perspectives from LGBTQI+ scholars and thinkers in prescribed readings and other materials, or when possible. “Integrate supplemental materials, such as videos or additional resources, that feature voices from LGBTQI+ communities,” they say.

Brouard emphasises that the Trans Protocol is an “invitation” to think about the curriculum and pedagogy, not an “instruction”. “We invite academics to think about gender in new ways and to invigorate their curricula where appropriate. We are already thinking about curriculum through the lenses of transformation and decoloniality, and we think gender fits nicely into this work.”

Additional sources: Centre for Research on Learning and Teaching, University of Michigan; mypronouns.org

Copyright © University of Pretoria 2024. All rights reserved.

FAQ's Email Us Virtual Campus Share Cookie Preferences